Bay Shore, NY Utility & Living Guide

⚡ Amazon Prime Day 2026

Exclusive Deals for Your New Home

🛒 Shop Prime Day Deals Now

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Tier 3 Location

Bay Shore, NY Utility & Living Guide

Bay Shore offers a charming suburban lifestyle with easy access to the Great South Bay and vibrant downtown area.

Last updated: June 25, 2026
Total Utilities$305/mo
1BR Rent$1200/mo
Sales Tax7.5%
COL Index105 (+5% above national average)
Family Score6/10
Median Home$320,000
🌤️ Live Weather — Bay Shore
Loading weather...
📷 Live Cameras — Bay Shore
Live camera
Live · refreshing...
⚠️ Natural Hazard History — Bay Shore
Loading hazard data...
💼 Calculate Your Future Retirement Income

Moving Your Assets to Bay Shore?

Moving to Bay Shore? Find out how much retirement income you could generate based on your current savings, age, and goals. Calculate Your Retirement Income → Free · Takes 2 minutes · No personal data required
💰 Budget Calculator
🔌 Utilities
🏠 Housing
📊 Cost of Living
💰 Taxes
👨‍👩‍👧 Families
🧮 Tools

Monthly Utility Costs

⚡ Electric

$120/mo

PSEG Long Island
🔥 Gas

$50/mo

National Grid
💧 Water

$45/mo

Suffolk County Water Authority
🗑️ Garbage

$25/mo

Town of Islip
📶 Internet

$65/mo

Combined Average Overhead $305/month

Housing Market

Rent & Property
1 Bedroom$1200/mo
2 Bedrooms$1600/mo
3 Bedrooms$2100/mo
Median Home Price$320,000
Property Tax Rate1.2%
Avg Childcare/mo$1000

The Bay Shore housing market is competitive, with a mix of historic homes and modern developments. Prices have been rising steadily due to demand from commuters and families.

Cost of Living

Overall COL Index

105

US national avg = 100
vs National Avg

+5% above national average

Groceries

102

Transportation

98

Healthcare

100

Childcare/mo

$1000

Tax Rates

Tax Overview
Total Sales Tax7.5%
Property Tax Rate1.2%
<p>State 4% + County 3.5% + City 0%</p>

New York State has a progressive income tax system with rates ranging from 4% to 8.82%.

Family & Relocation

Family Vibe Score
6/10
Safety Index

50

Higher = safer
School Rating

6.5/10

GreatSchools avg
Avg Childcare

$1000/mo

City Pulse

Population Trend
+3% (growing)
Political Climate
Purple (mixed Democratic and Republican)
Business Momentum
Moderate with key industries in healthcare, retail, and maritime services.
Top Local Concerns
Property taxes, school funding, traffic congestion
🚌 Transit for Families

Public transit is limited, but sidewalks are generally well-maintained for strollers.

🎡 Top Kid Attractions
  • 🎯
    Bay Shore Marina
  • 🎯
    South Shore Nature Center
  • 🎯
    Bay Shore Brightwaters Public Library

Best Neighborhoods for Families

The downtown area is popular for its walkability, while the neighborhoods near the marina offer scenic views and family-friendly amenities.

Household Budget Calculator

Estimate your real monthly cost of living in Bay Shore based on your household profile.

Local Briefing & Neighborhood Pulse

Live Local News

Residents must obtain permits for home renovations and adhere to strict zoning laws for property modifications.

Bay Shore is experiencing growth in small businesses and local investments. Rising home values reflect its popularity as a commuter town near NYC.

Financial Tools

Calculators
Planning Tools

Find Another City Guide

Search by city name or ZIP code to find utility costs, housing data and cost of living guides.

📊 Bay Shore — Census & Demographic Data

Official data from the US Census Bureau, American Community Survey.

💰 Median Household Income
$97,783
👤 Median Age
35.6
🏠 Homeownership Rate
66.2%
🔑 Renter Rate
33.8%
📉 Poverty Rate
6.8%
💼 Unemployment Rate
4.3%
📡 Internet Access
89.4%
🎓 College Educated
27.7%

☀️ Seasonal Utility Costs

Utility costs peak in winter due to heating needs and in summer due to air conditioning usage. Spring and fall typically see lower utility bills.

🏛️ Local Tax Details

Key ZIP code level tax info: property tax millage rates vary by school district, with additional surtaxes for sewer and water improvements.

👶 Family & Stroller Friendliness

7/10: Sidewalks are generally good, parks are accessible, but public transit lacks elevator access for strollers.

🏠 Planning Your Move?

Shop moving supplies, storage solutions and home essentials

🛒 Shop on Amazon — Prime Day Deals

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.