Greece, New York — This Santorini sister island is Greece’s best-kept secret

Let’s be clear: the headlines may say “Santorini’s sister island,” but for New Yorkers, the real sister island is closer than you think. Greece, New York—the small town in Monroe County, not the Mediterranean nation—has long been overshadowed by its flashier neighbors along the Lake Ontario shoreline. But for those considering a relocation within the Empire State, this quiet hamlet is emerging as a compelling alternative.

Greece offers a rare blend: access to Rochester’s job market and cultural amenities without the urban price tag. Housing remains notably more affordable than in the city or its southern suburbs, with historic Colonials and ranch homes still within reach for families and young professionals. Here, the cost of living mimics that of a small town, yet residents have Lake Ontario beaches, miles of walking trails, and a growing farm-to-table food scene.

The “spectacular churches” and “ancient history” of Greek lore may not apply here, but the area offers its own historic charm—from the Greek Revival architecture lining North Greece Road to the community’s deep-rooted agricultural heritage. And while there’s no boutique hotel yet, the new mixed-use developments near Ridge Road hint at a shift toward walkable, modern living.

For anyone weighing a move from the boroughs or Westchester, Greece New York delivers what the headlines promise: a quieter pace, reasonable costs, and a sense of discovery. It’s worth watching not because it’s a secret, but because it proves you don’t need a passport to find a fresh start.

Source: Currents

View Greece city guide

Updated August 08, 2026.

Get your home essentials, storage, and moving supplies delivered.

Shop Moving Essentials

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.